In one of the most electrifying matches of the UEFA World Cup Qualifiers for 2026, Italy edged past Israel 5–4 in a rollercoaster contest that had everything—own goals, comebacks, defensive collapses, and a stoppage-time winner. Played at Nagyerdei Stadium in Debrecen, Hungary, on September 8, 2025, this Group I clash will be remembered not just for its scoreline but for the sheer emotional intensity and tactical chaos that unfolded over 90 minutes.

First Half: A Tale of Twists and Turns

The match began with Israel showing early intent, pressing high and forcing Italy into uncomfortable positions. Their aggression paid off in the 16th minute when Italy’s Manuel Locatelli inadvertently turned the ball into his own net, giving Israel a 1–0 lead. The goal stunned the Italians and energized the Israeli side, who looked confident and composed in possession.

Italy responded swiftly. Moise Kean, who had been lively from the outset, equalized in the 40th minute with a well-placed finish after a slick passing move. The momentum shifted, and Italy began to assert control in midfield through Nicolò Barella and Sandro Tonali. By halftime, the score was level, but the match was already simmering with tension.

Second Half: Chaos Unleashed

The second half exploded into life. Dor Peretz gave Israel a 2–1 lead in the 52nd minute, capitalizing on a defensive lapse. But Italy, refusing to be outdone, launched a furious counterattack. Kean struck again in the 54th minute, followed by Matteo Politano’s goal in the 58th, turning the game on its head at 3–2.

Italy’s Giacomo Raspadori added a fourth in the 81st minute, seemingly sealing the win. But Israel wasn’t finished. In a dramatic late surge, Alessandro Bastoni scored an own goal in the 87th minute, and Dor Peretz netted his second in the 89th, leveling the match at 4–4. The stadium erupted as Israel clawed back from a two-goal deficit in the dying minutes.

Just when it seemed the match would end in a draw, Sandro Tonali delivered the final blow in the 90+1st minute, scoring the decisive goal that gave Italy a 5–4 victory.

Tactical Breakdown

Italy lined up in a 4-2-3-1 formation, with Donnarumma in goal and a backline featuring Bastoni, Di Lorenzo, Dimarco, and Cambiaso. Locatelli and Barella anchored the midfield, while Politano, Frattesi, and Raspadori supported Kean up front. Despite the attacking firepower, Italy’s defense looked vulnerable throughout, especially under Israel’s high press and quick transitions.

Israel opted for a 4-4-2 setup, with Daniel Peretz in goal and a defensive unit led by Revivo, Lemkin, and Nachmias. Dor Peretz was the standout performer, notching two goals and driving the midfield with energy and precision. Manor Solomon and Oscar Gloukh added creativity, while Tai Baribo and Eliel Peretz provided attacking width.

Individual Performances

Moise Kean was Italy’s talisman, scoring twice and constantly threatening Israel’s backline. His movement off the ball and ability to find space were crucial in Italy’s attacking transitions. Matteo Politano also impressed, contributing a goal and several key passes.

For Israel, Dor Peretz was the undisputed star. His brace, combined with relentless midfield work, kept Israel in the game even when the odds were stacked against them. Daniel Peretz made several crucial saves, and Manor Solomon’s creativity was evident in the build-up play.

Defensive Fragility and Mental Resilience

Both teams displayed defensive vulnerabilities. Italy’s two own goals—by Locatelli and Bastoni—highlighted lapses in communication and composure under pressure. Israel, despite their spirited fightback, struggled to contain Italy’s attacking trio and left gaps that were ruthlessly exploited.

Yet, the mental resilience shown by both sides was commendable. Israel’s ability to come back from 4–2 down in the final minutes speaks volumes about their determination. Italy, on the other hand, showed grit by regaining composure and finding a winner in stoppage time.

Implications for Group I

With this win, Italy moves to 9 points in Group I, keeping pace with Norway and maintaining their qualification hopes. Israel, despite the loss, remains in contention but will need to tighten their defense and convert their attacking promise into consistent results.

This match could prove pivotal in the group standings, especially if goal difference and head-to-head results come into play.

Fan Reactions and Media Buzz

Social media exploded with reactions to the match. Fans praised the attacking spectacle, while pundits debated the defensive frailties and managerial decisions. Italian supporters celebrated Tonali’s late heroics, while Israeli fans expressed pride in their team’s fighting spirit despite the loss.

Final Thoughts

Israel vs Italy was more than just a qualifier—it was a footballing spectacle that reminded fans why the beautiful game is so beloved. Nine goals, dramatic twists, and last-minute heroics made this match an instant classic. For Italy, it was a vital win that keeps their World Cup dreams alive. For Israel, it was a heartbreaking defeat but one that showcased their potential and resilience.

As the qualifiers continue, both teams will need to learn from this match—Italy must shore up their defense, and Israel must find consistency in execution. But for now, fans can revel in the chaos, the brilliance, and the sheer unpredictability of a match that will be talked about for years to come.